Q1 2021 Options Review

Data Insights

DMMs Return to the Floor (and to Auctions)

Published
April 27, 2021

The NYSE Trading Floor, like all workplaces, has been affected by the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. After closing in March 2020, the Trading Floor partially re-opened to Floor Brokers in May 2020 and to Designated Market Makers (DMMs) in mid-June 2020; subsequent NYSE Research analysis highlighted the Floor’s re-opening and associated market quality benefits. In light of public health conditions, Floor capacity was restricted between December 28, 2020 and January 22, 2021, with DMMs operating remotely during this time.

DMMs’ presence on the Floor allows them to manually conduct auctions, adding human judgement to especially complex or challenging price discovery events. DMMs’ return to the Trading Floor on January 25th coincided with an increase in market volume and volatility, resulting in an increase in Limit Up/Limit Down (LULD) halts.

NYSE-Listed Consolidated Volume

Source: NYSE TAQ

LULD halts trigger a 5-minute trading pause, followed by a re-opening auction. LULD events are, by definition, associated with increased market volatility, and the re-opening auction can help establish a reference point as trading resumes. NYSE re-opening auctions after the DMMs returned to the Trading Floor are closer to subsequent market trading, showing the benefit of increased oversight and judgment.

LULD Re-opening Auction Average Dislocation

(% of Daily Trading Range)

Source: NYSE TAQ

“Auction Dislocation” is defined as the difference between the re-opening auction price and the volume-weighted average price (VWAP) observed in the market over the subsequent two minutes. Here we display this measure as a percentage of each stock’s Daily Trading Range, averaged across all NYSE-listed corporate stocks.

Recent articles


NYSE: Short-dated equity options survey results

March 15, 2024

Trading options contracts on expiration day, also known as short-dated options, averaged more than 40% of SPY options volume in 2023. When Wednesday expirations were added to five ETFs1 in November 2023, short-dated trading has gained market share in all five of them. The industry has been discussing the reasons behind the short-dated trading phenomenon and debating whether additional expirations should be considered for single stocks.

Read More

2023: The Year in U.S. ETPs - Part 3

February 1, 2024

2023 was an exceptional year for global equity ETPs. Until the fourth quarter, profits were limited generally to a few tech companies, but gains broadened in Q4. We review fund flows, returns and activity in multiple equity ETP categories.

2023: The Year in U.S. ETPs - Part 2

January 17, 2024

Actively managed ETPs now account for 1/3 of all U.S. ETP listings, accounting for 6.5% of AUM and 22.5% of fund flows in 2023. Futures-based Crypto ETP activity grew as the year progressed, likely in anticipation of the 11-Jan-2024 launch of cash bitcoin ETPs.

Read More